There is no universally right answer. It comes down to your size, how much of your business depends on technology, and how much you want to manage people versus contracts.
Managed IT tends to fit when
- You have fewer than about 50 people and no one whose job is IT.
- You need breadth, such as security, backup, networking and help desk, more than deep knowledge of one system.
- You want predictable monthly costs and coverage when someone is on vacation.
In-house tends to fit when
- You run specialized or custom systems that need someone who knows them intimately.
- Response time is measured in minutes, on-site, every day.
- You are large enough that a provider's per-user fee would exceed a salary plus tools.
The middle path: co-managed IT
Many growing businesses keep one or two internal IT people and contract a provider for the rest: after-hours coverage, security monitoring, projects and a second opinion. The internal team knows the business, and the provider brings tools and depth that are expensive to build alone.
Doing the math honestly
When comparing, count everything. For in-house that means salary, benefits, training, tools and licenses, and coverage when that person is out. For managed IT, count the monthly fee, project fees and anything excluded. Then ask which option gives you better security and less downtime, not just which is cheaper.