Most businesses pick an IT provider the way they pick a plumber: someone they know, or whoever answered first. That works until the first real outage. A few questions asked up front save a lot of pain later.
Start with what you need, not who is selling
Before you talk to anyone, write down four things. How many people and devices you have. What your business cannot run without, such as email, phones, a line-of-business app or card payments. Any compliance you answer to, such as HIPAA, PCI or CMMC. And what went wrong in the last year. Providers quote very differently to a buyer who has this on paper.
Ten questions to ask every provider
- How many clients do you support that are our size and in our industry? Can we speak to two of them?
- What exactly is included in the monthly fee, and what gets billed as a project or by the hour?
- What are your response and resolution times, and are they written into the contract?
- Who answers the phone when we call, and where are they?
- How do you back up our data, how often do you test a restore, and when did you last do one?
- What security tools come standard: MFA, endpoint protection, email filtering, patching?
- Who owns our admin passwords, domain, licenses and documentation if we leave?
- What does it cost to leave, and how long is the notice period?
- Will you bring a written plan for the next 12 months, or just fix things as they break?
- Do you carry cyber liability and errors-and-omissions insurance?
Red flags
- They won't put response times in writing.
- They want to hold your domain, Microsoft 365 tenant or admin accounts in their own name.
- They can't describe their last backup restore test.
- Auto-renewing multi-year terms with steep early-termination fees.
- The quote arrives before anyone has asked what your business actually does.
Compare proposals like-for-like
Put every proposal in the same table: per-user or per-device price, what is included, what is excluded, onboarding fees, contract length and exit terms. The cheapest monthly number often has the longest list of exclusions.